What happens to the periodontal (gum) health of 10 people if you put them in a Stone Age environment for 4 weeks with no toothbrushes?! This interesting, if small scale, study was undertaken by Baumgartner et al in 2009. The subjects’ periodontal health was measured at baseline using four indicators: bleeding on probing (BOP), gingival (GI) and plaque indices (PI) and probing depths (PD). The subjects who were participating in a Swiss TV documentary:
Four weeks later their periodontal health was re-assessed using the same measures. In the absence of modern oral hygiene you might have expected that their gums would have suffered. This is the case when similar studies are conducted without dietary changes.
In fact what was found was that only the level of plaque increased. With this diet, rich in antioxidants and and anti-inflammatory components and with no refined sugar, there was no clinical evidence of increased gingival inflammation and PD and BOP decreased over time.
The authors concluded: Diet matters in the control or development of gingivitis in the absence of oral hygiene measures over a 4 week period.
We’ll examine the relationship between nutrition and periodontal disease in future posts. For the moment it is sufficient to say that evidence for nutrition as a risk factor is growing but not yet sufficiently robust.

